Does your phone have an unhealthy hold on you?

Have you ever felt panicked when you have left home and realized that your cell phone was back at the house? If so, you are not alone. We are all becoming more reliant on devices in our daily life.
For some people that can be a problem. A survey done by the health data management firm Harmony Healthcare IT found that on average, Americans spend five hours and 16 minutes per day on their cell phones. The same survey found that 53 percent of those people wanted to cut down on cell phone usage and 49 percent believed that they were addicted to their phones. That percentage increases to 69 percent for Gen Z (people born between 1997 and 2012). Seventy-two percent of that same group believes that their mental health would improve if apps were less addictive and 69 percent believe their social life would improve with less screen time.
The issue got worse during the COVID-19 pandemic. During the lockdown, people relied more on screens for work, school and socialization. When the pandemic ended, the reliance on screens continued. A recent study by Pew Research Center found that 48 percent of Americans said that the pandemic changed the way they currently use technology.
How It Affects Our Brains
Clinical psychologist Krista Lesinski, PsyD, who works at Cape Cod Healthcare Behavioral Health Services, said the topic of cell phone addiction comes up often with her clients.
“Cell phone addiction is not recognized as a mental disorder yet, but there is absolutely a lot of research coming out about it and it’s definitely talked about in my groups,” she said. “So, I wouldn’t be surprised if it ends up becoming some sort of mental health disorder diagnosis or going under a category coming up in the near future.”
Clients talk to Lesinski about losing sleep ‘doom scrolling’ or watching TikTok videos at night. They lose track of time until, all of a sudden, it’s 2 a.m. Most people don’t realize how much time they are spending on their phones. A large part of the problem is that each swipe and ding gives us a jolt of dopamine, the feel-good hormone. That makes us crave more hits. That is similar to the way our brain reacts to a substance abuse disorder, Lesinski said.
How to Know if You Have a Problem
The signs and symptoms of cell phone addiction are similar to other addictions, she said. They include:
- Lying about how often you’re on your cell phone.
- People in your life making comments about how often you are on your cell phone.
- Engaging less socially as cell phone use increases.
“I think engaging less socially is a big one because sometimes people start isolating, canceling plans, missing appointments and being late for things,” Lesinski said.
She advises people to think about the feelings you are trying to get or trying to avoid by constantly staying connected to your cell phone. She suggested asking yourself the following questions:
- Am I on my phone because I’m bored?
- Am I on my phone because I’m lonely?
- Am I on my phone because I’m feeling sad?
“I think that’s an important piece of this, too; why am I doing this and what else could I try to do to relieve this feeling to try to fill that void in a healthier way?” Lesinski said.
What to Do
With substance abuse, the treatment is to completely stop using the substance. But that’s impossible to do when it comes to technology, which is woven into our lives in complex ways.
“We still have to be connected to technology, so you can’t 100 percent limit your access to it like you can with a substance use disorder,” she said. “You have to be able to navigate boundaries with it – to be able to use it for a certain part of my life, but then shutting it down before it becomes problematic.”
While there are some recovery groups like Internet and Technology Addicts Anonymous that operate in a similar manner as other 12-step programs, the closest chapter is in Cambridge, which means that joining a Zoom meeting is the best option for Cape Codders interested in joining a group. The Cambridge group uses lines – top, middle and bottom – to separate cell phone behavior into categories, from most detrimental to advantageous. The lines are:
- Bottom lines are the things you feel are most destructive or addictive. This can include short videos, social media and news websites.
- Middle lines are the actions that can be done in moderation but should be limited to avoid falling into bottom lines. This could include email, texting and online shopping.
- Top lines are the actions that are beneficial behaviors, such as exercise, meditation apps and other things that help you avoid unhealthy behaviors.
“I like the idea of downloading some blocker apps,” Lesinski said. “Or on the phone sometimes you can set social media limits for yourself, where after an hour, your phone will tell you you’ve reached your limit for the day and it will blank it out on your phone.”
Lesinski has actually used this on her own phone because she likes to be mindful of how long she is on it. Her clients have also told her about putting their phones into gray scale mode.
“They say it’s less engaging so it doesn’t trigger as much dopamine,” she said. “I’ve heard people have success with that as well.”